Which Brain is Working on Healthcare?

Is any brain right?

Hillarykare… Obamakare… Pelsoikare… three different brains, three different ideas… all at odds with the wishes of the American people.  According to the dean of Harvard Medical School, make that an “F” instead:

Worse, currently proposed federal legislation would undermine any potential for real innovation in insurance and the provision of care. It would do so by overregulating the health-care system in the service of special interests such as insurance companies, hospitals, professional organizations and pharmaceutical companies, rather than the patients who should be our primary concern.

In effect, while the legislation would enhance access to insurance, the trade-off would be an accelerated crisis of health-care costs and perpetuation of the current dysfunctional system—now with many more participants. This will make an eventual solution even more difficult. Ultimately, our capacity to innovate and develop new therapies would suffer most of all.

A “Special Commission on the Health Care Payment System” recently declared that the Massachusetts health-care payment system must be changed over the next five years, most likely to one involving “capitated” payments instead of the traditional fee-for-service system. Capitation means that newly created organizations of physicians and other health-care providers will be given limited dollars per patient for all of their care, allowing for shared savings if spending is below the targets. Unfortunately, the details of this massive change—necessitated by skyrocketing costs and a desire to improve quality—are completely unspecified by the commission, although a new Massachusetts state bureaucracy clearly will be required.

Selling an uncertain and potentially unwelcome outcome such as this to the public would be a challenging task. It is easier to assert, confidently but disingenuously, that decreased costs and enhanced quality would result from the current legislation.

We should not be making public policy in such a crucial area by keeping the electorate ignorant of the actual road ahead.

Which brain would you pick?

Did you like this article? If so, get new articles every day for free via RSS or Email

Related posts:

1. Whole Foods and Healthcare – What Irony!
2. Healthcare in France
3. Michelle Obama Wants Lower Survival Rates for Breast Cancer
4. Congress Won't Take the Medicine They Prescribe
5. How Much is a Baby's Life Worth Under Socialized Healthcare?