It's Not Corny, It's Government Policy

Corn = Cash!

Corn = Cash!

Why I am against any government favoring one form of energy production (solar, wind, coal, etc…) over the other can be explained by the enthanol debacle.  It sounds like a good idea… reduce American oil imports by using something we have in great abundance – the ability to grow corn – and blend it with gasoline in order to extend our fuel supplies.  The U.S. will use less oil, farmers will have a crop they can sell, and unfriendly regimes that sell us their black gold will get less of our dollars.

That was the promise (or should I say the hot air) about ethanol.  Let’s examine what happens when the U.S. government throws taxpayer dollars behind such an idea.

According to a recent article in the Wall Street Journal:

Back in 2005, Congress passed a highway bill. In its wisdom, it created a subsidy that gave some entities a 50-cents-a-gallon tax credit for blending “alternative” fuels with traditional fossil fuels. The law restricted which businesses could apply and limited the credit to use of fuel in motor vehicles.

Not long after, some members of Congress got to wondering if they couldn’t tweak this credit in a way that would benefit specific home-state industries. In 2007, Congress expanded the types of alternative fuels that counted for the credit, while also allowing “non-mobile” entities to apply. This meant that Alaskan fish-processing facilities, for instance, which run their boilers off fish oil, might now also claim the credit.

What Congress apparently didn’t consider was every other industry that might qualify. Turns out the paper industry has long used something called the “kraft” process to make paper. One byproduct is a sludge called “black liquor,” which the industry has used for decades to fuel its plants. Black liquor is cost-effective, makes plants nearly self-sufficient, and, most importantly (at least for this story), definitely falls under Congress’s definition of an “alternative fuel.”

What paper industries did was use this law (which Congress passed and President George W. Bush signed into law) to apply for credits adding up, depending upon who you listen to, from $3 billion to $6 billion of taxpayer dollars!  Also, another unintended result of this entire program is that other countries (namely Canada) say that this money is, in effect, an unfair subsidy that provides American paper companies with an advantage when compared to their Canadian counterparts.

Pony up U.S. taxpayer.

Pony up U.S. taxpayer.

Not only are these industries sucking down taxpayer dollars but the diversion of cropland for corn to be used for ethanol has raised food prices as more and more corn has been diverted for fuel production instead of for human and animal consumption.  As for consumers, ethanol holds less energy per gallon than gasoline does so cars fueled with E85 (85% gasoline, 15% enthanol) do not travel as far and need to be refueled more often.

These ethanol subsidies cost U.S. taxpayers $8 billion in 2008.  And, it has turned out, all of the money that was spent building ethanol refineries and infrastructure is going to waste:

Corn ethanol plants “are shutting down virtually every week.” An alternative energy trade group says at least 10 of the nation’s 150 ethanol firms have closed some 24 plants in three months, with a dozen other companies in distress.

Little more than a year after the Democratic Congress passed legislation launching a massive national effort to convert farm crops and agricultural wastes into auto fuel, it’s become clear that the production deadlines aimed at greenifying your local gas station can’t and won’t be met.

The many investors who were tripping all over themselves to finance biofuel plants last year are finding that going green can mean losing lots of green.

All of this comes on the heels of President Obama’s desire to tax CO2 emissions, which the EPA just classified as a pollutant, the first step on the way to regulating it, which could cost as much as $2 trillion dollars and place heavy burdens on the poor, their employers, and make U.S. industry non-competitive because these taxes do not exist in countries like China and Japan.

You’d think that if the EPA said CO2 was a pollutant that all of the “money” raised would go towards “fighting” it, right?  Wrong… it will be spent on health care reform!

Governments do not belong in “picking winners” in any area whether it be cars, energy, or sofa beds.  One look at the unintended consequences of ethanol and “alternative” energy production should give everybody food for thought.

Did you like this article? If so, get new articles every day for free via RSS or Email

  • WordPress
  • Delicious
  • Digg
  • Facebook
  • Google Buzz
  • Twitter
  • StumbleUpon
  • Share/Bookmark

Related posts:

  1. Getting Energized
  2. Comrade, Your Government is Ready

6 Comments

  • The paper industry example in the WSJ is a perfect example of what economists call “unintended consequences.” We will have to live through more government waste for the foreseeable future as long as people believe that the federal government should be mandating “green” initiatives.

    vulcanhammer’s last blog post..How To Rid Government Corruption!

  • Great post. Very informative and really a great read. Thanks for this.

    Brian Anderson’s last blog post..Health care: Do the Dems want it now?

  • Harrison,
    I couldn’t agree more with you on this one. The government -subsidized ethanol program has been a total disaster. Not only did the diversion of corn for fuel production reduce the world’s food supply, but it did little to reduce the demand for fossil fuels.
    The whole issue of developing alternative energy sources for America is very complicated. Last year when the oil producers (namely OPEC) were selling oil at $147 a barrel, everyone was scrambling for alternatives; now that oil is $47 a barrel no one cares about alternatives. The problem is we are very vulnerable to the oil exporting countries for our critically needed energy supplies. Once the world-wide recession eases off, and demand pressures begin to out-strip supplies the price for a barrel of oil will shoot right back up to $147.
    Whatever the future may bring in terms of oil prices, we all know that it’s only a matter of time (maybe a few decades) before the easily accessible oil supplies will be gone, and supply & demand pressures will determine where we go from there. I am very, very leery about the government creating artificial supply curves based on what they think the future holds for energy supplies. This kind of central planning almost never works.

    askcherlock’s last blog post..Earth to Gliese 581; Come in Please

    • I agree that is why it is disaster to allow them to interfere. Allow energy exploration to take a natural course and not be the result of fits and starts that happen because politicians force one type of energy on us instead of another (solar instead of nuclear for example).

  • Malcolm Stuckey

    To all fellow fair minded and working people

    I would like to register my disgust at all the political parties for their utter contemp of the working class and middle class people of Britain.

    The exposure of elected labour party ministers of the Cabinet charging for second homes and expenses that quite frankly are insulting the intelligence of the people who put trust in their elected politicains.

    They should have the decency to resign. They seem to think one rule for us and another for working people who work hard for their money and if you are self employed Inland Revenue insist on receipts for all purchases, and quite right.

    When is somebody going to stand up for us and the high taxes that finance this gravy train. It’s our hard earnt money these politicians are spending. Who said we wanted to spend billions on fighting wars we are never going to win. Please lets get organised to demonstrate against these policitians who treast us as cash machines, we will have to demonstrate our utter disgust at these people in public life who are letting us down.

  • Once again an excellent written post from you. Keep it up!

Leave a Reply


CommentLuv Enabled

More on Liberals

  • Liberals Obama on Economy: I Feel Your Pain (Not!)

    Obama on Economy: I Feel Your Pain (Not!)

    Obama says he is “not that far removed from what most Americans are going through.” It almost sounds like something that was made up.  Here’s President Obama telling the millions of unemployed Americans he feels their pain: President Obama says he can relate to the plight of...

    Read more →
  • Liberals Liberals Simply Lie

    Liberals Simply Lie

    He screams racism where it doesn’t exist. Howard “The Scream” Dean went on Fox News Sunday to tell the world that Fox News was… get ready for it… racist!  Dean did allow that the host of the show, Chris Wallace, wasn’t racist (whew!) and fellow guest Newt Gingrinch...

    Read more →
  • Liberals Death Tax, George Steinbrenner, and Family Ownership

    Death Tax, George Steinbrenner, and Family Ownership

    Steinbrenner’s family won’t have his money taken by the government. Why should the State get take any of your money just because you died?  Taxing anybody’s estate is simply theft by legislation.  Liberals will make the argument that it only affects “the rich” and...

    Read more →
  • Liberals Dodd-Frank Financial Reform Bill: By Crooks For “Crooks”

    Dodd-Frank Financial Reform Bill: By Crooks For “Crooks”

    Takes one to know one. The U.S. Senate passed the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform Bill.  Democrats sold it as a way to “tame” Wall Street.  Maybe we should examine the question of whether anything worthy can come from the two crooks who’s name appears on the bill. Senator Chris...

    Read more →
  • Liberals U.S. Shorts Itself on Spy Swap: 10 for 4

    U.S. Shorts Itself on Spy Swap: 10 for 4

    Comrade, enlightened Liberal president will free you! The captured Russian spies, whom Vladimir Putin said weren’t really spies, ended up getting traded for 4 spies being held in Russia.  Of those 4 spies, one wasn’t “working” for America and another didn’t even want to...

    Read more →
  • Liberals Obama Appoints Healthcare Czar – 100 Million People, No Hearings

    Obama Appoints Healthcare Czar – 100 Million People, No Hearings

    Berwick wants wealth redistribution and rationing. President Obama arrogantly named a new chief for Medicare – 100 million Americans will be under his “care” – and Congress hadn’t even had the chance to vet or even question him.  Donald Berwick is an expert at two things:...

    Read more →
  • Liberals Obama’s NASA Feelgood Mission: Muslims in Space!

    Obama’s NASA Feelgood Mission: Muslims in Space!

    A return to the Crescent Moon? Just when you thought Liberals couldn’t get any weirder, we have the head of NASA being tasked with the job of making Muslims “feel good” about their past contributions to math and science: “When I became the NASA administrator — or before I became...

    Read more →
  • Liberals Big Government: Illegal in UK to Sell Eggs By the Dozen

    Big Government: Illegal in UK to Sell Eggs By the Dozen

    EU Nanny State says no more by the dozen! The European Union super state – a collection of bureaucrats who are not accountable to any voters – has ruled that it’s against the law to sell eggs by the dozen: British shoppers are to be banned from buying eggs by the dozen under new regulations...

    Read more →
  • Liberals Crazy Liberals in San Francisco Enact Cell Phone Radiation Law, City Loses Money

    Crazy Liberals in San Francisco Enact Cell Phone Radiation Law, City Loses Money

    CTIA – the Wireless Association, will no longer have its conferences in San Francisco after this year.  The reason? The group is taking its show elsewhere (along with 68,000 attendees and $80m in economic activity according to CTIA), a response to the cellphone radiation law passed by the San...

    Read more →
  • Liberals Things Made from Oil: Why Obama's Wrong

    Things Made from Oil: Why Obama's Wrong

    We can all come to the conclusion that the oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico is a tragedy but the posturing we are hearing from the president and his party about the need to “ween America off of oil” is just plain absurd.  Oil is responsible for the lives we have today, both in terms of the...

    Read more →